Friday, March 27, 2009

Abolishing Windfall Tax in Zambia

The euphoria on the mining tax regimes that were introduced by the late Preseident Mwanawasa in 2008 is quickly over, like a flash in the pan. It is clear that the late president had a lot of pretensious followers in his party that were not happy with the introduction of new fiscal tax policy for the mining sector. In retrospect, some of them may have rubbed their hands with glee that he passing because his demise presented them the opportunity to make under-handed deals with mining companies to enrich themselves. The pace at which the then new tax regime was soon quickly suspended after President LPM's death and now finally abolished is disheartening.

It is preposterous for Zambia to continue on the current path of economic destruction. Like I have said before on other fora, Zambians need to speak out and demand the right to know how those deals and future deals are made with mining companies. In order to promote transparency, there is need for government to make all the agreements public so that the public can appraise themselves of the various conditionalities in the agreements. However, this is likely to face alot of opposition and resentment from government officials especially in scenarios where some or the majority of the deals may be questionable and largely lack integrity.

The removal of the well-intended windfall tax regime will significantly affect the only major opportunity of Zambia benefiting from its own natural resources and wealth through an effective tax collection policy. Revenues which were hitherto highly promising will now be driven down to the extent that we may begin to entertain ideas that mining conglomerates in Zambia own our wealth.  All the ongoing political manoeuvers should serve as warnings to all Zambians that the country is quickly slipping back to Chiluba's time when the economic plunder machine was let loose. 

4 comments:

Chola Mukanga said...

Welcome to the blogosphere!

I look forward to reading your thoughts!!

MrK said...

Great website and blog.

I would suggest the following:

Scrap all taxes on the mining companies, except one, the royalty tax, which is a tax on turnover, and increase it from 3% to 20% or more, and collect in copper to build copper reserves.

This would make it impossible and irrelevant for the mining companies to understate profits, hide profits, employ accounting tricks, claim losses, etc. By simplifying procedures, it also reduces the opportunity for corruption - except in parliament, because those bought and paid for by the mining companies are bound to raise all kinds of 'objections'.

They can do whatever they want, as long as 20% of copper goes straight to the GRZ.

Here are some older articles that are worth reading:

Sickening irresponsibility on mineral royalty tax
By Editor
Friday March 30, 2007 [02:00]


Magande quiet on mine contracts
By Kingsley Kaswende
Friday March 30, 2007

Freedom of information legislation is critical - Jolly
By Speedwell Mupuchi, Masuzyo Chakwe and Bright Mukwasa
Friday March 30, 2007

World Bank official urges govt to renegotiate mining contracts
By Speedwell Mupuchi
Thursday March 29, 2007

MrK said...

Revenues which were hitherto highly promising will now be driven down to the extent that we may begin to entertain ideas that mining conglomerates in Zambia own our wealth. All the ongoing political manoeuvers should serve as warnings to all Zambians that the country is quickly slipping back to Chiluba's time when the economic plunder machine was let loose.

I think there is a serious problem with the mines being represented better in parliament than the people are - which is a direct violation of democracy itself.

We all know that when these issues come up, we get all kinds of contributors coming out of the woodwork making all kinds of improbable claims on why the mines should never be taxed, how there are 'higher values' than taxing the mines, etc. ;)

You know who they are.

At the same time, the government should be streamlined to provide services to the people, and the way to do that is to give half of national revenues to local government, and empower them to provide the basic services of healthcare, education, security/compliance and amenities. That would radically change the country for the better.

And tax the heck out the mines.

Unknown said...

A big welcome to the blogosphere!We have talked and head each other on blog talk radio its time to fill the gap.

All the best!!